Previous Entry Share Next Entry
A realization on star wars
gasmask
keskitsune
The concept of the jedi/sith duality in star wars always bugged me for some reason. I know, overanalyzing silly movie religion, but at the same time, I never quite figured out what exactly was the defining thing that bugged me. However, a few minutes ago, it came to me exactly what did bug me about the whole thing:

 
[17:09] <Sparks> Only a Sith deals in absolutes.
[17:09] <KesKittaur> Sparks, but isn't that an absolutist statement in and of itself
[17:10] <KesKittaur> doesn't this mean that jedi themselves are sith?

This was something the original series hinted at a few times, but never really overtly said. The prequels on the other hand used this as a hammer in several places and eliminates any sympathy one may have for the supposed heroes, which I think was what killed the franchise there.

Warning: Heresy

The same heavy handedness is also why I didn't like Empire Strikes Back. It felt too...well...too heavy handed in the attempts to be Serious Science Fiction. Lucas is wonderful at the concept of Technicolor Space Opera -- bright, colorful, not too serious, epic space scenes, etc. However, much like technicolor, the subtlety gets lost somewhere along the way. The depth, the shadows, the unevenness of characters are what makes things wonderful and dark; I just have never felt that Empire had those things.
Tags: ,

  • 1
Pretty much with you on this: Lucas has a great imagination, but the movies suffered because he's not actually very good as a writer or director. The Star Wars mythos was both a good idea and the beneficiary of good luck as far as a variety of cultural factors.

That's usually been my point as well. And the 'prequels' confirmed my opinion on the whole deal. There's the Jedi Council, the supposed goodguys... and... nothing else. According to them the last Sith lord was gone for a long time, but something tells me that Diplomacy didn't kill off all the Sith.

They were right when they got scared of Anakin being 'the one that will bring balance to the Force', since the scales were kinda tipped... And one kid supposedly being The Balance means either all of them would be gone except for the kid, or the kid would oppose them, all by himself. Which he mostly did.

In my opinion, the Jedi and the Sith are the same coin, and not neccesarily opposite sides. I'd even go as far as to call the Jedi the more dangerous evil.
Just look here...

Sith: "Hey mister planet leader. I think I know better than you and you should do what I say."
Leader: "And what if I don't?"
Sith: "We'll kill you and then blow up your planet. Simple as that."
Leader: "Oh, well, I better do what you say."
Sith: "Good boy."

OR

Jedi: "Hey mister planet leader. I think I know better than you and you should do what I say."
Leader: "And what if I don't?"
Jedi: "I know better than you and you should do what I say." *handwave*
Leader: "You know better than me and I will do what you say."
Jedi: "Good boy."

Jedi = Sith = Jedi = Sith = Just some buggers with Real Ultimate Power, both use it to control people, governments and/or planets. One of them's just more forwards in it than the other.

  • 1
?

Log in

No account? Create an account